Author: Аni Нarutyunyan
Keywords: “another inhumane act”; a crime against humanity; Al-Mahdi case; attack against cultural property; persecution; war crime
The Al-Mahdi case at the International Criminal Court (ICC) was a signal to armed groups and governments that attacks against cultural property cannot go unpunished. Ahmad Al Faqi Al-Mahdi was convicted by the ICC for committed war crimes of intentionally directing attacks against historical buildings and monuments. Still, while applying the provision of the war crime of attacking cultural property, the Court went beyond the strict content of the war crime of attacking cultural property, as codified in the Rome Statute; “attack” in the context of the Rome Statute has a specific meaning and refers to a combat action during a military operation. The attacks against cultural property in the Al-Mahdi case were not part of a combat action in the course of a military operation. Rather, they were carried out as part of law enforcement activities in the territories controlled by the armed groups. The Al-Mahdi case was a lost opportunity to bring charges of persecution as a crime against humanity before the ICC, even though according to the Rome Statute and customary international law the act of attacking cultural property may amount to a crime against humanity. In addition, both practice and opinion juris provide that attacks against cultural property per se may constitute “another inhumane act” of a crime against humanity. However, the law is blurred and it does not fall under the jurisdiction of the ICC, unlike other crimes against humanity. Nevertheless, the Rome Statute does not hinder the development of this norm of international law.
About the author: Аni Нarutyunyan – MA, Adv. LL.M (Leiden University, Netherlands), independent researcher, Moscow, Russia.
Citation: Нarutyunyan А. (2017) Delo Al-Mahdi i napadenie na kul’turnye tsennosti kak mezhdunarodnoe prestuplenie [The Al-Mahdi case and attack against cultural property as an international crime]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, no.2, pp.118–132. (In Russian).
Bassiouni C. (2010) Crimes against Humanity: The Case for a Specialized Convention. Washington University Global Studies Law Review, vol.9, no.4. pp.575–593.
Bassiouni C., Hannat M.W. (2007) Ceding the High Ground: The Iraqi High Criminal Court Statute and the Trial of Saddam Hussein. Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law, vol.39, no.1–2. pp.21–97.
Blinderman E. (2009) The Conviction of Saddam Hussein for the Crime against Humanity of “Other Inhumane Acts”. University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law, vol.30, no.4, pp.1239–1264.
Cryer R., Friman H., Robinson D., Wilmshurst E. (2015) An Introduction to International Criminal Law and Procedure, 3rd ed., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
DeGuzman M.M. (2016) Applicable Law. In: Triffterer O., Ambos K. (eds.) The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: A Commentary, 3rd ed., München: Beck; Oxford: Hart; Baden-Baden: Nomos, pp.932–948.
Dörmann K. (2004) Elements of War Crimes under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: Sources and Commentary, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ehlert С. (2014) Prosecuting the Destruction of Cultural Property in International Criminal Law: With a Case Study on the Khmer Rouge’s Destruction of Cambodia’s Heritage, Leiden; Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Francioni F. (2004) Beyond State Sovereignty: The Protection of Cultural Heritage as a Shared Interest of Humanity. Michigan Journal of International Law, vol.25, no.4, pp.1209–1228.
Frulli M. (2005) Advancing the Protection of Cultural Property through the Implementation of Individual Criminal Responsibility: the Case-Law of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia.The Italian Yearbook of International Law, vol.15, pp.195–216.
Frulli M. (2015) The Contribution of International Criminal Tribunals to the Development of International Law: The Prominence of opinio juris and the Moralization of Customary Law. The Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals, vol.14, no.1, pp.80–93.
Geras N. (2011) Crimes against Humanity: Birth of a Concept, Manchester; New York: Manchester University Press.
Gottlieb Y. (2005) Criminalizing Destruction of Cultural Property: A Proposal for Defining New Crimes under the Rome Statute of the ICC. Penn State International Law Review, vol.23, no.4, pp.857–896.
Hall C.K., Powderly J., Hayes N. (2016) Crimes against Humanity. In: Triffterer O., Ambos K. (eds.) The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: A Commentary, München: Beck; Oxford: Hart; Baden-Baden: Nomos, pp.206–225.
Hall C.K., Stahn C. (2016) Crimes against Humanity. In: Triffterer O., Ambos K. (eds.) The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court: A Commentary, 3rd ed., München: Beck; Oxford: Hart; Baden-Baden: Nomos, pp.144–294.
Hector M. (2010) Enhancing Individual Criminal Responsibility for Offences involving Cultural Property – the Road to the Rome Statute and the 1999 Second Protocol. In: Van Woudenberg N., Lijnzaad L. (eds.)Protecting Cultural Property in Armed Conflict: An Insight into the 1999 Second Protocol to The Hague Convention of 1954 for the Protection of Cultural Property in Armed Conflict, Leiden; Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, pp.69–76.
Henckaerts J.M., Doswald-Beck L. (2005) Customary International Humanitarian Law. Vol.2: Practice, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hladík J. (2012) Different Legal Issues Related to the Protection of Cultural Property in Peacetime and Wartime. American Society of International Law, vol.106, pp.453–462.
Hopkins R. (2016) The Case 002/01 Trial Judgment: A Stepping Stone from Nuremberg to the Present? In: Meisenberg S.M., Stegmiller I. (eds.) The Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia: Assessing their Contribution to International Criminal Law, The Hague: T.M.C. Asser Press, pp.181–201.
Kila J.D. (2015) From Crimes against Art to Crimes against Cultural Property: New Perspectives and Dimensions in Art Crime. In: Kila J.D., Balcells M. (eds.) Cultural Property Crime: An Overview and Analysis of Contemporary Perspectives and Trends, Leiden; Boston: Koninklijke Brill, pp.167–205.
Kuschnik B. (2008) The Legal Findings of Crimes against Humanity in the Al-Dujail Judgments of the Iraqi High Tribunal: A Forerunner for the ICC? Chinese Journal of International Law, vol.7, no.2, pp.459–483.
Martínez S.G. (2015) Destruction of Cultural Heritage in Northern Mali: A Crime against Humanity?Journal of International Criminal Justice, vol.13, no.5, pp.1073–1097.
Nerlich V. (2009) The status of ICTY and ICTR Precedent in Proceedings before the ICC. In: Stahn C., Sluiter G. (eds.) The Emerging Practice of the International Criminal Court, Leiden; Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, pp.305–326.
Newton M. (2006) The Iraqi High Criminal Court: Controversy and Contributions. International Review of the Red Cross, vol.88, no.862, pp.399–425.
O’Keefe R. (2010) Protection of Cultural Property under International Criminal Law. Melbourne Journal of International Law, vol.11, no.2, pp.339–392.
Petrovic J. (2013) The Old Bridge of Mostar and Increasing Respect for Cultural Property in Armed Conflict, Leiden; Boston: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Powderly J. (2015) The Rome Statute and the Attempted Corseting of the Interpretative Judicial Function: Reflections on Sources of Law and Interpretative Technique. In: Stahn C. (ed.) The Law and Practice of the International Criminal Court, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.444–498.
Pictet J., Sandoz Y., Swinarski Ch., Zimmermann B. (eds.) (1987) Commentary on the Additional Protocols of 8 June 1977 to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, Geneva: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Schabas W. (2010) The International Criminal Court: A Commentary on the Rome Statute, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Schabas W.A. (2011) Crimes against Humanity as a Paradigm for International Atrocity Crimes. Middle East Critique, vol.20, no.3, pp.253–269.
Schabas W. (2012) Unimaginable Atrocities: Justice, Politics, and Rights at the War Crimes Tribunals, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Werle G., Jessberger F. (2014) Principles of International Criminal Law, 3rd ed., Oxford: Oxford University Press.