Category

Ключевые слова: International Criminal Court

A commentary to the Judgment of the Appeals Chamber of the International Criminal Court in the case of Prosecutor v. Bosco Ntaganda from 15 June 2017

A commentary to the Judgment of the Appeals Chamber of the International Criminal Court in the case of Prosecutor v. Bosco Ntaganda from 15 June 2017

Kristina Russkikh – Postgraduate student, Faculty of Law, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia.

DOI: 10.21128/2226-2059-2017-4-26-33

Abstract. In its Judgment from 15 June 2017, the International Criminal Court confirmed its jurisdiction in the case of Bosco Ntaganda and indicated that the sexual exploitation and rape of child soldiers by members of their own armed group constitute a war crime. This decision of the ICC provoked much controversy among experts in the field of international criminal law. Some experts consider this Judgment to be a real breakthrough in the protection of child soldiers from sexual slavery by their own armed group, which before remained “invisible” for international criminal law, while many child soldiers, mostly girls, suffer from violations of their right to sexual integrity. Others accuse the Court of abuse of power and the “blurring” of the definition of a war crime, in an attempt to interpret international humanitarian law based on provisions that in reality it does not contain. This commentary examines the definition of a war crime under the ICC Statute and the validity of this judgment. Additionally, the connection of this case with the first Court’s decision on the issue of child soldiers in the Lubanga case is considered. The commentary covers the problem of the active participation of child soldiers in hostilities, the expansion of the scope of applying the norms on war crimes, and judicial activism. The issue of active participation of child soldiers in hostilities itself generates much controversy since the recognition of active parti­cipation protects them from certain crimes, but denies protection from others. The ICC attempted to elect the most advantageous position for the protection of child soldiers, but what consequences this entails is still unknown.

Keywords: war crime; child soldiers; International Criminal Court; sexual exploitation; armed conflict.

Citation: Russkikh K. (2017) Seksual’naya ekspluatatsiya detey-soldat ikh vooruzhennoy gruppoy kak voennoe prestuplenie: Kommentariy k Postanovleniyu Apellyatsionnoy palaty Mezhdunarodnogo ugolovnogo suda po delu Prokuror protiv Bosko Ntagandy ot 15 iyunya 2017 goda [The sexual exploitation of child soldiers by their armed groups as a war crime: A commentary to the Judgment of the Appeals Chamber of the International Criminal Court in the case of the Prosecutor v. Bosco Ntaganda of 15 June 2017]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosu­die, no.4, pp.26–33. (In Russian).

Otto Triffterer (1931–2015)

Abstract The essay is dedicated to the passing of Professor Otto Triffterer, an outstanding scholar in the field of international criminal law, who made a

Beneficial difference

By subscribing, you save 900 rubles and save time. Get a new number by e-mail or Russian Post