CCR №4 (137) 2020
Constitutionalization of the human dignity concept

Abstract

It’s impossible to imagine a modern constitution without provisions on human dignity. This concept has an impact on human rights provisions and is a necessary component of constitutional statehood. At the constitutional level, human dignity can be positioned as a principle of law that defines the goals or grounds for the adoption of the Constitution, a specific human right or as a ground for permissible restriction of constitutional rights and freedoms. Some constitutive acts enshrine the collective dignity of social groups or peoples, but this approach is not very common. The concept of dignity is an open one, it applies to all areas of human activity. In spite of its universal recognition, the interpretation of this concept is largely determined by the specific characteristics of the constitutional development of a particular country. Constitutional disputes concerning human dignity can be classified on the basis of the nature of claims against the state (ensuring respect to individual autonomy, providing a minimum set of socioeconomic benefits for a decent existence, protection from human dignity infringements by public officials or third parties). This concept allows the constitutional review bodies to identify areas of individual freedom and those human rights violations that affect self-worth as well as to identify new trends in the development of law and society.

About the author:
Tatiana Vasilieva – Doctor of Science in Law, Associate Professor, Chief Research Fellow, Human Rights Department, Institute of State and Law, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia

Citation: Vasilieva T. (2020) Kostitutsionalizatsiya kontseptsii dostoinstva cheloveka [Constitutionalization of the human dignity concept] Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.29, no.4, pp.98–110. (In Russian).

References

Abat i Ninet A. (2019) Self-Determination as an Expression of Collective Human Dignity: The Case of Catalonia. The Italian Law Journal, vol.5, no.1, pp.1–17.

Amaral M.A. (2014) The Principle of Human Dignity in the Case-Law of the Portuguese Constitutional Court. Constitutional Justice in the New Millennium: Almanac, Yerevan: Tsentr Konstitutsionnogo prava Respubliki Armeniya, pp.104–110.

Benák J., Vyhnánek L., Zahumenský D. (2019) Human Dignity in Czech Republic. In: Becchi P., Mathis K. (eds.) Handbook of Human Dignity in Europe, Cham: Springer, pp.197–210.

Botha H. (2009) Human Dignity in Comparative Perspective. Stellenbosch Law Review, vol.20, no.2, pp.171–220.

Carmi G.E., Shultziner D. (2013) “Dignitizing” Constitutions Worldwide: On the Proliferation of Human Dignity in National Constitutions. Available at: https://www.academia.edu/27398524/Dignitizing_Constitutions_Worldwide_On_the_Proliferation_of_Human_Dignity_in_National_Constitutions (accessed: 11.07.2020).

Cornell D., Woolman S., Fuller S., Brickhill J., Bishop M., Dunbar D. (eds.) (2013) The Dignity Jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court of South Africa: Cases and Materials, in 2 vols., New York: Fordham University Press.

Daly E. (2013) Dignity Rights. Courts, Constitutions, and the Worth of the Human Person, Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.

Daly E., May J.R. (2017) A Dignity Right Synopsis. Available at: https://delawarelaw.widener.edu/files/resources/adignityrightssynopsisdalymay.pdf (accessed: 11.07.2020).

Drigo C. (2015) Principles in Constitutional Jurisprudence. The Principle of Human Dignity and the Epistemological Challenges for the Interpreter — Some Brief Reflections on the Recent Case Law of the Italian Constitutional Court. The Turkish Yearbook of International Relations, vol.46, pp.23–46.

Henry L.M. (2011) The Jurisprudence of Dignity. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, vol.160, no.1, pp.169–233.

Laviņš A. (2014) The Constitutional Status of Human Dignity: Case-Law of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Latvia. In: Almanac “Constitutional Justice in the New Millennium”, Yerevan: Tsentr Konstitutsionnogo prava Respubliki Armeniya, pp.87–98.

Loureiro J.C. (2019) Human Dignity in Portugal. In: Becchi P., Mathis K. (eds.). Handbook of Human Dignity in Europe, Cham: Springer, pp.719–744.

Macklin R. (2003) Dignity is a Useless Concept. British Medical Journal, vol.327, no.7429, pp.1419–1420.

Mathis K., Hammer B. (2019) Human Dignity in Switzerland. In: Becchi P., Mathis K. (eds.) Handbook of Human Dignity in Europe, Cham: Springer, pp.883–933.

Moyn S. (2014) The Secret History of Constitutional Dignity. Yale Human Rights and Development Law Journal, vol.17, no.1, pp.39–73.

Pierrot E.-J. Realising Social and Economic Rights through the Courts: Lessons and Experiences from South Africa, Israel and the USA. Available at: https://www.wcmt.org.uk/sites/default/files/migrated-reports/900_1.pdf (accessed: 11.07.2020).

Pino G.G. (2016) Human Dignity in Chilean Law and Constitutional Jurisprudence. In: Global Constitutionalism and Multi-layered Protection of Human Rights. Exploring the Possibility of Establishing a Regional Human Rights Mechanism in Asia, Seoul: Constitutional Court of Korea, pp.309–328.

Resta G. (2019) The Comparative Law of Dignity: An Introduction. Roma Tre Law Review, no.1, pp.108–119.

Sangiuliano A.R. (2015) Substantive Equality as Equal Recognition: A New Theory of Section 15 of the Charter. Osgoode Hall Law Journal, vol.52, no.2, pp.601–646.

Schachter O. (1983) Human Dignity as a Normative Concept. American Journal of International Law, vol.7, no.4, pp.848–854.

Shultziner D., Carmi G.E. (2014) Human Dignity in National Constitutions: Functions, Promises and Dangers. American Journal of Comparative Law, vol.62, no.2, pp.461–490.

Silvestri G. Considerazioni sul valore costituzionale della dignità della persona. Available at: https://www.associazionedeicostituzionalisti.it/old_sites/sito_AIC_2003-2010/dottrina/libertadiritti/silvestri.html (accessed: 11.07.2020).

Sperti A. (2019) Le Corti costituzionali tra tutela del pluralismo e delle singole identità. DPCE Online, vol.40, no.3, pp.2151–2164.

Tretyakov K. (2016) Corporate Identity and Group Dignity. Washington University Jurisprudence Review, vol.8, no.2, pp.172–218.

Valdés E.G. (2009) Dignity, Human Rights, and democracy. In: Baurmann M., Lahno B. (eds.). Perspectives in Moral Science: Contributions from Philosophy, Economics, and Politics in Honour of Hartmut Kliemt, Frankfurt am Main: Frankfurt School Verlag, pp.253–265.

Issue articles