CCR №2 (141) 2021
Constitutionalization of the principle of respect for elders: the experience of the 2020 constitutional amendments, their content and implementation problems

The full text of the article is available only in Russian.

Abstract

The article is devoted to the study of a number of problems related to the regulation and implementation of the principle of respect for elders, which is new for the constitutional law of Russia. The author substantiates the position that the problem of constitutionalization of the principle of respect for elders should be posed wider, at least outside the boundaries of strictly educational activities and in the broader context of the paradigm of the hierarchy of seniority in the system of fundamental principles of constitutionalism. The principle of “respect for elders” is opposed by the stable constitutional practice of Russia and foreign countries guaranteeing at the constitutional level, on the one hand, the rights of parents (mothers, fathers) and the elderly, and on the other, children and youth. Parents and the elderly do indeed enjoy the constitutional right to special respect as a kind of “elder”, but this does not give grounds for a broad interpretation of the constitutional status of all other members of society. The author proves that, in fact, the constitutional imperative of “respect for elders” is an attempt, albeit relatively “soft” in the legal sense (without legal consequences and in the absence of a clear definition of the rights and obligations of subjects of legal relations), to introduce into the life of a free civil society a kind of disciplinary-subordination beginning in relationships between older and younger people. Moving up the age ladder supposedly should give a certain increase in subjective rights. However, to what extent is this permissible in a constitutional state and a democratic society? And does this really correspond to the prevailing socio-cultural stereotypes of social behavior of the modern generation of Russians? According to the author, in the construction of “respect for elders”, an indication of the sign of seniority is of key importance. The term “respect” is not entirely accurate, since without significant distortion of the meaning it could be replaced with the words “special recognition”, “subordination”, “emphasized correct behavior”, etc. By virtue of Article 21 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, all people are obliged to respect each other as people, they are legally stimulated in equal measure to recognize the value of their human dignity.

About the author:
Pavel Astafichev — Doctor of Sciences in Law, Professor, Department of Constitutional and International Law, Saint Petersburg University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, Saint Petersburg, Russia

Citation: Astafichev P. (2021) Konstitutsionalizatsiya printsipa uvazheniya k starshim: opyt konstitutsionnykh popravok 2020 goda, ikh soderzhanie i problemy realizatsii [Constitutionalization of the principle of respect for elders: the experience of the 2020 constitutional amendments, their content and implementation problems]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.30, no.2, pp.180–191. (In Russian).

References

Babkin A.I. (2015) Rossiyskiy sud’ya: distsiplina v professional’noy i povsednevnoy zhizni [Russian judge: discipline in professional life and day-to-day routine]. Rossiyskiy sud’ya, no.3, pp.3–6. (In Russian).

Verigina E.V. (2009) Sorevnovanie kak metod ukrepleniya distsipliny i povysheniya motivatsii k deya­tel’nosti sotrudnikov OVD [Competition as a method of strengthening the discipline and raising motivation of intellectual affairs officers]. Psikhopedagogika v pravookhranitel’nykh organakh, no.4, pp.75–76. (In Russian).

Gritsay L.A. (2013) Ideal’nye predstavleniya i povsednevnaya real’nost’ detsko-roditel’skikh vzaimo­otnosheniy v kul’ture Drevney Rusi [Perfect ideas and everyday reality of child-parent relationships in the culture of Kievan Rus’]. Pedagogika i prosveshchenie, no.2, pp.142–150. (In Russian).

Esipova L.Yu. (2015) Vospitanie uvazhitel’nogo otnosheniya detey starshego doshkol’nogo vozrasta k sem’e [Education of respect of children of the advanced preschool age for a family]. Psikhologiya, sotsiologiya i pedagogika, no.1, pp.34–35. (In Russian).

Zhumateva A.S. (2018) Idei vospitaniya detey uvazheniyu starshikh v kyrgyzskoy poslovitse [Ideas of education of children of respect for elders in the Kyrgyz proverb]. Vestnik Bishkekskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta, no.1, pp.39–40. (In Russian).

Zuzaeva M.S., Khizriev Kh.A. (2011) Obychai i traditsii chechentsev: uvazhenie k starshim [Customs and traditions of the сhechens: respect for the elders]. In: Meterialy V ezhegodnoy respublikanskoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii molodykh uchenykh, aspirantov i studentov “Nauka i molodezh”, 2011, 3–4 iyunya [Materials of the V annual republican scientific and practical conference of young scientists, students and graduate students “Nauka i molodezh”, 2011, 3–4 June], Grozny: Chechenskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet, pp.56–60. (In Russian).

Konovalova A.M. (2018) Svyaz’ razvoda roditeley s pokazatelyami otsenochnogo i predpisannogo uvazheniya podrostkov k roditelyam [Connection of parents’ divorce with indicators of estimated and prescribed respect of adolescents for their parents]. In: Rebyonok i pravosudie. Materialy Vserossiyskoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii [Child and justice. Materials of the All-Russian scientific and practical conference], Moscow: Akademiya prikladnoy psikhologii i psikhoterapii, pp.80–83. (In Russian).

Kuznetsov R.A. (2020) Voinskaya distsiplina — osnova voennoy sluzhby na sovremennom etape [Military discipline — the basis of military service at the present stage]. Voenno-pravovye i gumanitarnye nauki Sibiri, no.2, pp.1 72–176. (In Russian).

Lebedev V.A. (2012). Prava cheloveka v sovremennoy Rossii [Human rights in modern Russia]. Prob­lemy prava, no.6, pp.9–14. (In Russian).

Nasurova I., Gadzhieva Z. (2017) Osobennosti otnosheniya k pozhilym v musul’manskoy kul’ture [Features of the attitude to elders in Muslim culture]. Byuletten’ meditsinskikh internet-konferentsiy, no.1, p.136. (In Russian).

Nekrasov S.I., Borodavko L.T. (2007) Tsennostnoe edinstvo nravstvennosti i prava [Valuable unity of morality and Law]. Uspekhi sovremennogo estestvoznaniya, no.11, pp.114–116. (In Russian).

Polyakov A.V. (2015) Vozmozhno li vozrozhdenie idey estestvennogo prava v Rossii? [Is revival of the natural law in Russia possible?]. Pravodedenie, no.5, pp.6–16. (In Russian).

Potemkina A.I., Kuzemina E.F. (2017) Uvazhenie k starshim kak nravstvennaya norma [Respect for the elders as a moral norm]. In: Gumanitarnye nauki. Sbornik nauchnykh rabot molodykh uche­nykh Kubanskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnologicheskogo universiteta [Humanitarian cciences. Collection of scientific works of awarded young scientists of the Kuban State Technological University], Krasnodar: Kubanskiy gosuderstvennyy tekhnologicheskiy universitet, pp.66–68. (In Russian).

Titarenko O.N. (2011) Partiynaya distsiplina kak faktor nivelirovaniya sindroma emotsional’nogo vygoraniya [Party discipline as a factor of leveling the burnout syndrome]. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov SWorld, no.4, pp.52–54. (In Russian).

Fyodorov V.V. (2014) Problemy regulirovaniya deyatel’nosti politicheskikh partiy i partiynoy distsip­liny [Problems of regulation activities of political parties and party discipline]. Izvestiya vysshikh uchebnykh zavedeniy. Ural’skiy region, no.6, pp.17–21. (In Russian).

Issue articles