CCR №2 (141) 2021
Legal restrictions on the right of association in political parties and their interpretation in court decisions: comparative legal analysis

The full text of the article is available only in Russian.

Abstract

The article examines the issue of exercising the freedom of association in political parties in Russia in a comparative analysis with the leading democratic countries of the world. Modern democracies cannot be imagined without political parties, which are the representors of the interests of their voters in legislative bodies and local government bodies. The development of civil society and the entire political system in the country depends on how the freedom of association in political parties and the access of parties to participate in elections is realized. The development of legislation on political parties in the Russian Federation proceeded unevenly. In the first years after the adoption of the Constitution the legislative body did not introduce strict requirements for parties. The adoption of a special federal law on political parties in 2001 became a turning point in the development of the party system. The author identifies two large blocks of restrictions on the creation of parties. The first is legislative restrictions, the second is the restrictions that arise from the unfair activities of legislative and law enforcement agencies. In this work, legislative restrictions are compared with restrictions in other democracies, as well as based on legal positions developed by the European Court of Human Rights. The author comes to the opinion that some restrictions on the creation of parties are not necessary now, in the meantime they significantly narrow the possibilities of party creation and political competition. First, we are talking about a ban on the creation of regional parties. The Constitutional Court in its legal positions indicated that this restriction is temporary and will be lifted over time. Within the framework of this work, the author will give suggestions on changing the approach to the creation of political parties in Russia, which should affect the emergence of new strong parties at different levels of public authority. The author believes that a system of “controlled multiparty system” has developed in Russia, which is implemented both in changing the legislation on political parties based on the interests of the “party in power” and the practice of the registration body, which prevents the formation of new parties claiming to redistribute the existing distribution of forces. Based on the analysis of the legislation on political parties, law enforcement practice, decisions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, the ECHR and the legislation of foreign countries, the author proposes approaches to reforming the existing party system, which include small cosmetic changes and large-scale changes in approaches to the creation of parties.

About the author:
Andrey Vershinin — Chief Legal Advisor, Legal Support Centre for Expert Assessments and Research, Institute for Applied Political Studies, Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia

Citation: Vershinin A. (2021) Zakonodatel’nye ogranicheniya prava na ob’edinenie v politicheskie partii i ikh interpretatsiya v sudebnykh resheniyakh: sravnitel’no-pravovoy analiz [Legal restrictions on the right of association in political parties and their interpretation in court decisions: comparative legal analysis]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.30, no.2, pp.149–179. (In Russian).

References

Aron R. (1993) Demokratiya i totalitarizm [Démocratie et totalitarisme], G.I.Semenov (transl.), Moscow: Tekst. (In Russian).

Avak’yan S.A. (2011) Konstitutsionno-pravovoy status politicheskikh partiy v Rossii: uchebnoe posobie [Legal constitutional status of political parties in Russia: a study guide], Moscow: Norma: Infra-M. (In Russian).

Bizzarro F., Gerring J., Knutsen C.H., Hicken A., Bernhard M., Skaaning S.-E., Coppedge M., Lindberg S. (2018) Party Strength and Economic Growth. World Politics, vol.70, no.2, pp.275–320.

Duverger M. (2013) Politicheskie partii [Les partis politiques], L.A.Zimina (transl.), Moscow: Akademicheskiy proekt; Gaudeamus. (In Russian).

Ebzeev B.S. (2011) Reshenie Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka po delu “Respublikanskaya partiya Rossii protiv Rossii”, ili utrachennye illuzii o garmonichnoy preemstvennosti obshcheevropeyskikh pravovykh standartov [The decision of the European Court of Human Rights Republican party of Russia v. Russia, or lost illusions about the harmonious continuity of common European legal standards]. Yuridicheskaya tekhnika, no.5, pp.545–555. (In Russian).

Franz P. (1982) Unconstitutional and Outlawed Political Parties: A German-American Comparison. Boston College International and Comparative Law Review, vol.5, no.1, pp.51–89.

Gauja A. (2014) Building Competition and Breaking Cartels? The Legislative and Judicial Regulation of Political Parties in Common Law Democracies. International Political Science Review, vol.35, no.3, pp.339–354.

Gauja A., Sawer M. (2014) Party Rules: Promises and Pitfalls. In: Gauja A., Sawer M. Party Rules? Dilemmas of Political Party Regulation in Australia, Acton, ACT: ANU Press, pp.1–36.

Gerra L.L. (2013) Pretsedentnaya praktika Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka v otnoshenii politicheskikh partiy [Precedent practice of European Court of Human Rights in case of political parties]. In: Politicheskie partii v demokraticheskom obshchestve: pravovye osnovy organizatsii i deyatel’nosti. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii, Sankt-Peterburg, 27–28 sentyabrya 2012 g. [Political parties in democratic society: legal aspects of their activities and organization. Proceedings of international conference, Saint Petersburg, 27–28 September, 2012], Moscow: Norma, pp.9–22. (In Russian).

Ismailov R.R. (2009) Konstitutsionno-pravovoy status politicheskikh partiy v Germanii, Avstrii, Shveytsarii: osnovnye tendentsii pravovogo regulirovaniya [Constitutional legal status of political parties in Germany, Austria, Switzerland: basic aspects of legal regulation]. Sotsiologiya prava, no.3, pp.131–138. (In Russian).

Ivanov S.S. (2016) Khristianskaya demokratiya: ideologiya i politika [Christian democracy: ideology and politics]. Vestnik Povolzhskogo instituta upravleniya, no.1, pp.114–121. (In Russian).

Kynev A.V., Lyubarev A.E. (2011) Partii i vybory v sovremennoy Rossii: Evolyutsiya i devolyutsiya [Parties and elections in modern Russia: Evolution and devolution], Moscow: Fond “Liberal’naya missiya”; Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. (In Russian).

Lapaeva V.V. (1999) Pravo i mnogopartiynost’ v sovremennoy Rossii [Law and multi-party system in modern Russia], Moscow: Norma. (In Russian).

Makarenko B.I. (ed.) (2015) Partii i partiynye sistemy: sovremennye tendentsii razvitiya [Political parties and party systems: modern tendencies of development], Moscow: Politicheskaya entsiklo­pediya. (In Russian).

Rashkova E.R., van Biezen I. (2014) The Legal Regulation of Political Parties: Contesting or Promoting Legitimacy? International Political Science Review, vol.35, no.3, pp.265–274.

Vershinin A. (2020) Izbiratel’nye bloki: opyt primeneniya i perspektivy vozvrashcheniya instituta v izbiratelnuyu sistemu Rossii [Electoral blocs: application experience and prospects of returning the institute to the electoral system of Russia]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.29, no.1, pp.81–106. (In Russian).

Volodina S.V. (2016) Mnogopartiynost’ kak osnova konstitutsionnogo stroya Rossii: monografiya [A multi-party system as the basis of the constitutional system of Russia: a monograph], Moscow: Prospekt. (In Russian).

Zor’kin V.D. (2013) Pravovye osnovy rossiyskoy mnogopartiynosti i praktika Konstitutsionnogo Suda [Legal grounds of Russian multi-party system and practice of the Constitutional Court]. In: Poli­ticheskie partii v demokraticheskom obshchestve: pravovye osnovy organizatsii i deyatel’­nosti: Materialy mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii, Sankt-Peterburg, 27–28 sentyabrya 2012g. [Political parties in democratic society: legal aspects of their activities and organization: Proceedings of international conference, Saint Petersburg, 27–28 September, 2012], Moscow: Norma, pp.22–44. (In Russian).

Issue articles