This essay argues that invoking the concept of the “constituent power” clarifies some persistent puzzles about the constitutional and legal status of purportedly unconstitutional constitutional amendments. It argues that in some circumstances such amendments should be understood as exercises of the constituent power, effecting revolutionary transformations in a nation’s constitutional identity but–sometimes–through the forms of legality. The status of constitutions as law is indexed to time through discrete exercises of the constituent power. A provision that is unconstitutional at one period of time can be constitutional at another time period, if the originary constituent power has been exercised at some intermediate point. The originary constituent power is exercised in constitutional revolutions, which are not necessarily violent or illegal. In sum, this essay uses the theme of the unconstitutional constitutional amendment as the vehicle for providing some insights into what the constituent power “is”. The author summarizes his conclusions in showing that the constituent power can exercise itself through the forms of legality, but those forms cannot ultimately constrain the constituent power. The essay distinguishes between a purely conceptual version of the constituent power and a more sociological or real-world version, and argues that the former is superior to the latter.
About the author
Mark Tushnet – William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Law, Harvard Law School
Citation: Tushnet M. Krest’yane s vilami i rabochie s tvitterom: konstitutsionnye revolutsii i konstituiruyushchaya vlast’ [Peasants with pitchforks, and toilers with Twitter: Constitutional revolutions and the constituent power]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, 2016, no. 2, pp. 15–31 (In Russian).
Albert R. (2010) Constitutional Handcuffs. Arizona State Law Journal, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 663–715.
Amar A. R. (1994) The Consent of the Governed: Constitutional Amendment Outside Article V. Columbia Law Review, vol. 94, no. 2, pp. 457–508.
Anderson B. (1991) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, rev. and expanded ed. London: Verso, 1991.
Arato A. (2014) Time and Sequence in Changes of Constitutional Regimes. I-CONnect Blog. Available at: http://www.iconnectblog. com/2014/06/time-and-sequence-in-changes-of-constitutional-regimes/ (accessed 26.02.2016).
Bernal-Pulido C. (2013) Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments in the Case Study of Colombia: An Analysis of the Justification and Meaning of the Constitutional Replacement Doctrine. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 339–357.
Child S. R. (1926) Revolutionary Amendments to the Constitution. Constitutional Review, vol. 10, pp. 27–35.
Colón-Ríos J. (2010) The Legitimacy of the Juridical: Constituent Power, Democracy, and the Limits of Constitutional Reform. Osgoode Hall Law Journal, vol. 48, no. 2, pp. 199–246.
Corrales J., Penfold M. (2011) Dragon in the Tropics: Hugo Chávez and the Political Economy of Revolution in Venezuela, Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press.
Cross F. B., Tiller E. H. (2000) The Three Faces of Federalism: An Empirical Assessment of Supreme Court Federalism Jurisprudence. Southern California Law Review, vol. 73, no. 4, pp. 741–771.
Jackson V. C. (2013) Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendment: A Window on Constitutional Theory and Transnational Constitutionalism. In: Bäuerle M., Dann P., Wallrabenstein A. (eds.) Demokratie-Perspektiven: Festschrift für Brun-Otto Bryde, Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, p. 47–76.
Jacobsohn G. (2014) Theorizing the Constitutional Revolution. Journal of Law and Courts, vol 2, no. 1, p. 1–32.
Jefferson T. Тo Major Thomas Cartwright, June 5, 1824. Founders Online, National Archives. Available at: http://founders.archives.gov/documents/ Jefferson/98-01-02-4313 (accessed 26.02.2016).
Kalyvas A. (2005) Popular Sovereignty, Democracy, and the Constituent Power. Constellations, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 223–244.
Khosla M. (2012) The Indian Constitution. New Delhi; Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kuo M.-S. (2010) Reconciling Constitutionalism with Power: Towards a Constitutional Nomos of Political Ordering. Ratio Juris, vol. 23, no. 3, pp. 390–410.
Landau D. (2013) Abusive Constitutionalism. University of California Davis Law Review, vol. 47, no. 1, pp. 189–260.
Lindahl H. (2007) Constituent Power and Reflexive Identity: Towards an Ontology of Collective Selfhood. In: Loughlin M., Walker N. (eds.) The Paradox of Constitutionalism: Constituent Power and Constitutional Form, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 9–24.
Marbury W. L. (1919) The Limitations Upon the Amending Power. Harvard Law Review, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 223–235.
Oklopic Z. (2013) Drafting Independence: The Catalan Declaration of Sovereignty and the Question of the Constituent Power of the People in Context. I-CONnect Blog. Available at: http://www.iconnectblog.com/2013/02/drafting-independence-the-catalan-declaration-ofsovereignty-and-thequestion-of-the-constituent-power-of-the-people-in-context/ (accessed 26.02.2016).
Preuss U. K. (1995) Constitutional Revolution: The Link Between Constitutionalism and Progress, Amherst: Prometheus Books.
Preuss U. (2011) The Implications of “Eternity Clauses”: The German Experience. Israel Law Review, vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 429–448.
Roznai Y., Yolcu S. (2012) An Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendment—The Turkish Perspective: A Comment on the Turkish Constitutional Court’s Headscarf Decision. International Journal of Constitutional Law, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 175–207.
Scheppele K. L. (2012) On the Unconstitutionality of Constitutional Change: An Essay in Honor of László Sólyom. In: Viva vox iuris civilis: tanulmányok Sólyom László tiszteletére 70. születésnapja alkalmából [Liber Amicorum in Honor of László Sólyom] / P. Sonnevend, B. Schanda, Z. Csehi (eds.), Budapest: Szent István Társulat, pp. 286–310.
Scheppele K. L. (Forthcoming) Unconstitutional Constituent Power. In: Smith R., Beeman R. (eds.) Constitution Making, Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Schmitt C. (2007) The Concept of the Political, G. Schwab (transl.), Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
Schmitt C. (2008) Constitutional Theory, J. Seitzer (trans.), Durham: Duke University Press.
Smith E. (2011) Old and Protected? On the “Supra-Constitutional” Clause in the Constitution of Norway. Israel Law Review, vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 369–388.
Tribe L. H. (2008) The Invisible Constitution, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Tso K. (2014) Constitutionalism Under Siege: The Court’s Role in the Face of Military Coups, Armed Uprisings and the “Stress of Necessity”. Public Law, no. 4, pp. 682–697.
Moscow, Shchepkina str., 8
+7 (495) 608-69-59
+7 (495) 608-66-35