CCR №2 (141) 2021
The constitutional human rights in Uzbekistan: positivism, traditionalism, and a cautious shift towards international legal standards

The full text of the article is available only in Russian.

Abstract

Until recently, unofficial interpretations of the situation with human rights had remained as an unspoken taboo in Uzbekistan, whereas foreign observers harshly criticized the country, pointing out systematic violations and restrictions of rights by the state. Indeed, not many could predict that the new President Shavkat Mirziyoev, who was elected in 2016, would initiate steps towards improving the human rights situation and, simultaneously, face specific challenges. The 1992 Constitution was developed within the complex transition process from socialism to market economy. This Constitution devotes an entire chapter to human and citizens’ rights. Initially, some authors expected that the Constitution would integrate rights in the context of natural-legal ideas. However, Uzbekistan has largely preserved and strengthened the positivist approach towards constitutional rights, designating the state to grant and limit those rights. The paradox of this situation is that Uzbekistan’s tendencies conflict with the general trends of the post-socialist constitutionalism since the country practically did not change constitutional provisions’ evolutionary development. On the other hand, in the post-socialist Eastern European countries and some former USSR republics, the collapse of socialism led to a constitutional revolution. The author applies historical analysis and cognitive constitutionalism methods to explain a paradox of impossibility to root natural-legal ideas within the (1) deeply-rooted Soviet positivism and (2) revived pre-Soviet traditionalism. On the other hand, the historical 1992 Constitution preparatory process, guided by the special Working group and headed by Islam Karimov, and the theory of human rights in Uzbekistan inherited a strong influence from the doctrine of the Soviet constitutionalism; its positivism, dogmatism and normativism. On the one hand, the author focuses on the impact of traditionalism revived after 1991 in national customs, behavioural attitudes, or social values; and paternalism that had transformed into a “super-presidentialism”, which widely continued a principle of the state’s priority above the individual. In conclusion, the author points to the existing legal imperfections of the constitutional text, and offers approaches to shorten the gap between the supporters of positivism in the 1992 Constitution and the natural right theory’s followers.

About the author:
Aziz Ismatov — Doctor of Sciences in Law, Assistant Professor at Center for Asian Legal Exchange, Nagoya University, Nagoya, Japan

Citation: Ismatov A. (2021) Konstitutsionnye prava cheloveka v Uzbekistane: pozitivizm, traditsionalizm i osto­rozhnyy razvorot v storonu mezhdunarodno-pravovykh standartov [The constitutional human rights in Uzbekistan: positivism, traditionalism, and a cautious shift towards international legal standards]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.30, no.2, pp.94–130. (In Russian).

References

Agzamkhodzhaev A.А., Blinder B.А. (1980) Yuridicheskiy fakul’tet TashGU [Law faculty at Tashkent state university], Tashkent: O’qituvchi. (In Russian).

Bazarov M. (2014) Sovetskaya religioznaya politika v Sredney Azii v 1918–1930 [The soviet religion policies in Central Asia in 1918–1930], Dushanbe: Irfon. (In Russian).

Cassese A. (2011) Five Masters of International Law: Conversations with R.-J.Dupuy, E.Jiménez de Aréchaga, R.Jennings, L.Henkin and O.Schachter, London: Bloomsbury Publishing.

Cole D. (2003) Are Foreign Nationals Entitled to the Same Constitutional Rights as Citizens? Thomas Jefferson Law Review, vol.25, no.2, pp.367–388.

Donnelly J. (1982) Human Rights as Natural Rights. Human Rights Quarterly, vol.4, no.3, pp.391–405.

Evans A. (1977) Developed Socialism in Soviet Ideology. Soviet Studies, vol.29, no.3, pp.409–428.

Feldbrugge F., Ferdinand J., van den Berg G., Simons W. (eds.) (1985) Encyclopedia of Soviet Law, London: Brill.

Ismatov A. (2019) Legal Education in Uzbekistan: Historical Overview and Challenges of Transition: CALE Discussion Paper no.18, Nagoya: Nagoya University. Available at: http://cale.law.nagoya-u.ac.jp/_userdata/CALE%20Discussion%20PaperNo18.pdf (accessed: 22.04.2021).

Ismatov A. (2020) Specifics of the Late Soviet Constitutional Supervision Debate: Lessons for Central Asian Constitutional Review? In: Ismatov A., Makino E. (eds.) Emergence and Features of the Constitutional Review Bodies in Asia: A Comparative Analysis of Transitional Countries’ Development: CALE Discussion Paper no.19, pp.77–93. Available at: http://cale.law.nagoya-u.ac.jp/_userdata/CALE%20Discussion%20PaperNo19.pdf (accessed: 22.04.2021).

Ismatov A., Alimdjanov S. (2018) Developmental Trajectory of Mahalla Laws in Uzbekistan: From Soft Law to Statutory Law. Nagoya University Asian Law Bulletin, vol.4, pp.1–28.

Ismatov A., Alimdjanov S. (2018) Historical Discourse of Mahalla Functions in Uzbekistan. Jahrbuch für Ostrecht, vol.59, no.1, pp.79–90.

Ismatov A., Ciklauri-Lammich E. (2018) Abolishing Capital Punishment in Uzbekistan — Between External Pressure and Pragmatism. Zeitschrift für die gesamte Strafrechtswissenschaft, vol.130, no.1, pp.279–302.

Femia J. (1979) Gramsci, the Via Italiana, and the Classical Marxist-Leninist Approach to Revolution. Government and Opposition, vol.14, no.1, pp.66–95.

Karimov I. (1993) Uzbekistan: svoy put’ obnovleniya i progressa [Uzbekistan: its way of renovation and progress], Tashkent: Uzbekiston. (In Russian).

Karimov I. (1993) Uzbekistan — sobstvennaya model’ perekhoda na rynochnye otnosheniya [Uzbekistan — its way of transition towards market relations], Tashkent: Uzbekiston. (In Russian).

Karimov I. (1996) O`zbekiston: milliy istiqlol, iqtisod, siyosat, mafkura [Uzbekistan: national independence, economy, politics and ideology], Tashkent: O`zbekiston. (In Uzbek).

Karimov I. (1997) Uzbekistan na poroge XXI veka: Ugrozy bezopasnosti, usloviya i garantii progressa [Uzbekistan on the edge of the XXI century. Security threats, conditions and guarantees of progress], Tashkent: Uzbekiston. (In Russian).

Katsapova I. (2012) Estestvennoe pravo i estestvennye prava [Natural law and natural rights]. Guma­nitarnye nauchnye issledovaniya, vol.11. Available at: http://human.snauka.ru/2012/11/1921 (accessed: 22.04.2021). (In Russian).

Khamedov I. (2018) Vospominaniya o nashem dorogom uchitele: nauchnoe nasledie i zhiznennyy put’ akademika A.Agzamkhodzhaeva [Remembering our dear mentor: scientific heritage and life path of academician A.Agzamkhodzhaev]. Vestnik Akademii General’noy prokuratury Respubliki Uzbekistan, no.2, pp.20–22. (In Russian).

Kornai J. (1992) The Socialist System: The Political Economy of Communism, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Levitin L. (1997) Pervyy prezident Respubliki Uzbekistan [The first president of the Republic of Uzbekistan], Tashkent: Uzbekiston. (In Russian).

Medushevsky A. (2006) Russian Constitutionalism: Historical and Contemporary Development, E.Luneva, T.Baeva (transl.), London; New York: Routledge.

Medushevsky A.N. (2017) Politicheskaya istoriya russkoy revolyutsii: normy, instituty i formy sotsial’noy mobilizatsii v XX veke [The political history of the Russian revolution: norms, institutes and social mobilization forms], Moscow; Saint Petersburg: Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ. (In Russian).

Medushevsky A. (2011) Kognitivnaya teoriya prava i yuridicheskoe konstruirovanie real’nosti [Cognitive theory of law and legal construction of reality]. Sravnitel’noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.20, no.5, pp.30–42. (In Russian).

Mengliev Sh.M. (2013) Kh.R.Rakhmankulov — vydayushchiysya uchyonyy, talantlivyy organizator, mudryy vospitatel’ [Kh.R.Rakhmakulov — outstanding scholar, talented manager and wise mentor]. Pravovaya zhizn’, no.4, pp.184–194. (In Russian).

Omelicheva M.Y. (2015) Democracy in Central Asia: Competing Perspectives and Alternative Strategies, Lexington, KY: University Press of Kentucky.

Partlett W. (2018) Postsovetskoe superprezidenstvo [Post-Soviet superpresidentialism]. Sravnitel’­noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie, vol.27, no.3, pp.103–123. (In Russian).

Partlett W., Ip E. (2016) Is Socialist Law Really Dead? New York University Journal of International Law & Politics, vol.48, pp.463–511.

Partlett W. (2021) Kyrgyzstan’s 2021 Constitution: A Brief Comparative and Historical Analysis (April 23): University of Melbourne Legal Studies Research Paper No.944, pp.1–17.

PetrovV., Semyonova V., Shkenеv K. (2016) Osnovy sotsial’nogo gosudarstva [Fundamentals of social state], Nizhniy Novgorod: Nizhegorodskiy gosudarstvennyy architekturno-stroitel’nyy universitet. (In Russian).

Rakhmаnkulov Kh. (2012) Konstitutsiyamiz 20 yoshda [The 20 years anniversary of our constitution], Tashkent: Tashkentskiy gosudarstvennyy yuridicheskiy universitet. (In Uzbek).

Rtveladze E. (2018) A.Kh.Saidov — Shtrikhi k biografii [A.Kh.Saidov — Biography sketches]. In: Akmal’ Kholmatovich Saidov. Biblioraficheskiy ukazatel’ trudov [Akmal Kholmatovich Saidov. Bibliographic index of works], Tashkent: Izdatel’stvo zhurnala San’at, pp.5–9. (In Russian).

Joseph S., Schultz J., Castan M. (2000) The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: Cases, Materials, and Commentary, New York; Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Saidov A. (2020) Sravnitel’noe pravovedenie: akademicheskiy uchebnik [Comparative law: a textbook], Moscow: Norma: INFRA-M. (In Russian).

Saidov A. (2018) O’zbekiston Konstitutsiyasi tarihi [The history of Uzbekistan’s Constitution], Tashkent: Tasvir. (In Uzbek).

Saidov A., Akhmedov G., Sattorov A. (eds.) (1991) Prava cheloveka i zakony [Human rights and laws], Tashkent: Shark. (In Russian).

Saidov A., Tadzhikhanov U. (2001) Islom Karimov Konstitutsiya to’grisida: O’zbekiston Respublikasining Konstitutsiyasi o’rganuvchilarga Yordam [Islam Karimov on Constitution of the Republic of Uzbekistan: a guidebook for researchers], Tashkent: Akademiya. (In Uzbek).

Saidov A., Tadzhikhanov U., Odylkoriev Kh. (2002) Osnovy gosudarstva i prava: uchebnik [Basics of state and law: a textbook], Tashkent: Shark. (In Russian).

Sarkisyants G. (1991) K razrabotke novykh osnov ugolovno-protsessual’nogo zakonodatel’stva [On elaboration of new basis of criminal-procedural legislation]. Obshchestvennye nauki v Uzbekistane, no.7, pp.18–26. (In Russian).

Smith G.B., Maggs P.B., Ginsburgs G. (eds.) (1981) Soviet and East European Law and the Scientific-Technical Revolution, New York; Oxford: Pergamon Press.

Trynkov A. (1998) Otnosheniya mezhdu Uzbekistanom i SShA [Uzbekistan and the USA relations]. In: Kozhokin E.M. (ed.) Uzbekistan: obretenie novogo oblika. Tom 2 [Uzbekistan: obtaining a new statehood. Vol.2], in 2 vols., Moscow: Rossiyskiy institut strategicheskikh issledovaniy, pp.225–259. (In Russian).

Urazaev Sh.Z. (1993) Konstitutsiya nezavisimogo Uzbekistana [The constitution of the independent Uzbekistan], Tashkent: Adolat. (In Russian).

Wiles P.J.D. (1962) The Political Economy of Communism, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Zor’kin V. (2011) Konstitutsionno-pravovoe razvitie Rossii [Constitutional legal development of Russia], Moscow: Norma: INFRA-M. (In Russian).

Issue articles